I read the first half of Robert D. Richardson's William James: In the Maelstrom of American Modernism in the spring, set it aside for a couple of months, then finally picked it back up and finished it a few weeks ago. Loved it!
Except for the occasional touch of pedantry, Richardson does an admirable job of compressing James' full life and voluminous writings into ~500 pages. He presents a man easy to admire, and difficult to pigeonhole — an analytical physiologist/psychologist/philosopher professing "a strong bias toward irrationalism," a Darwinist championing religion/spirituality and the paranormal, a scientist critical of the scientific mainstream...
Disbelief is just as stable as belief, so the "true opposites of belief, psychologically considered, are doubt and inquiry, not disbelief." Belief and disbelief, he insists, "are but two aspects of one psychic state."--- James...refuses what he bluntly calls "medical materialism," the view that the spiritual authority of a Saint Teresa can be undermined by classing her as a hysteric, that of a Saint Francis by calling him a hereditary degenerate, that of a George Fox by pointing to his disordered colon. "In the natural sciences and industrial arts it never occurs to anyone to try to refute opinions by showing up their author's neurotic constitution...It should be no otherwise with religious opinions."
James recognizes the power of belief, the "truth" of a gut feeling, a religious experience. His Truth is not fixed, not out there waiting to be discovered, perfect and whole. His Truth is life lived...action, experience, the personal, the connections between objects (rather than the objects themselves)...
People's sense of dramatic reality is what they will certainly obey, no matter how much they pretend to follow nothing but points of evidence.--- If this life be not a real fight, in which something is eternally gained for the universe by success, it is no better than a game of private theatricals from which one may withdraw at will. But it feels like a real fight — as if there were something really wild in the universe which we, with all our idealities and faithfulnesses, are needed to redeem; and first of all to redeem our own hearts from atheisms and fears. For such a half-wild, half-saved universe our nature is adapted.
--- [Fact and theory] are both made of the same...experience-material. The same material is 'fact' when it functions steadily; it is 'theory' when we hesitate...Truth is thus in process of formation like all other things...There is no eternally standing system of extra-subjective verity to which our judgments, ideally and in advance of the facts, are obliged to conform.
--- I am convinced that the desire to formulate truths is a virulent disease. It has contracted an alliance lately in me with a feverish personal ambition, which I never had before, and which I recognize as an unholy thing.
--- What most horrifies me in life is our brutal ignorance of one another.,
...we are doomed, by the fact that we are practical beings with very limited tasks to attend to, and special ideas to look after, to be absolutely blind and insensible to the inner feelings, and the whole inner significance of lives that are different from our own. Our opinion of the worth of such lives is absolutely wide of the mark, and unfit to be counted at all.
James, the exasperated anti-imperialist:
To the ordinary citizen the word anti-imperialist suggest a thin-haired being just waked up from the day before yesterday, brandishing the Declaration of Independence excitedly, and shouting after a railroad train thundering towards its destination to turn upon its tracks and come back.
James, the self-deprecating Harvard professor:
[T]o be a college man, even a Harvard Man, affords no sure guarantee for anything but a more educated cleverness in the service of popular idols and vulgar ends.
James, the writer:
[The day] looked as if God had just spit on his sleeve and polished up the universe till you could almost see your face reflected in it.
Upon completing William James, the bio, I was tempted to pick up a volume of James' own writings, but I decided I needed a break...so now I'm reading something a little less intellectually demanding: a comic book (Watchmen).
As a non-German speaker, I found this book to be rather amusing. It's "for Dummies" and I can't even make sense of the book cover...

























































Recent Comments